What are the Best Gay Bars in Fire Island?

Fire Island's bar scene is intimate but iconic, split between Cherry Grove and the Pines. Every venue is within walking distance of the ferry docks in its respective community.

Cherry Grove

• The Ice Palace — The island's most legendary venue, hosting drag shows, DJ nights, themed parties, and the famous BRÜT leather parties. The main dance floor and outdoor pool deck make it the center of Cherry Grove nightlife
• Sip·n·Twirl — A lively cocktail bar and tea dance spot in Cherry Grove's harbor area, popular for late-afternoon drinks and socializing before the evening begins
• Cherry's On The Bay — Waterfront restaurant and bar with a spacious bayside deck, known for drag brunches and Hedda Lettuce's weekly Monday shows

Fire Island Pines

• Pavilion — The Pines' flagship dance club, featuring top DJs, circuit party events, and Showtunes Sundays. The outdoor pool deck is a centerpiece of Pines social life
• The Blue Whale — The Pines' iconic waterfront bar, best known for its daily Tea Dance — the late-afternoon outdoor gathering that has been a Fire Island tradition for decades. Also hosts drag brunches on weekends

Browse all gay bars and nightlife in Fire Island on Out x Out.