Are There Lesbian Bars and Safe Spaces in Fire Island?
Fire Island's Cherry Grove has deep roots as a lesbian community — queer women began summering there in the 1950s, and the community has been a safe haven ever since. The historian Esther Newton documented this history in her book Cherry Grove, Fire Island: Sixty Years in America's First Gay and Lesbian Town.
Cherry Grove — The Heart of Queer Women's Fire Island
While Fire Island doesn't have a dedicated lesbian bar, Cherry Grove is the more gender-diverse of the two gay communities, with a strong presence of queer women, non-binary people, and LGBTQ+ families. The entire village functions as a safe space.
- The Ice Palace — Hosts events and parties that draw a mixed, inclusive crowd including many queer women
- Cherry's On The Bay — The waterfront restaurant and bar is a popular gathering spot for all parts of the community
- Arts Project of Cherry Grove — The community theater regularly features queer women artists, playwrights, and performers in its summer season programming
- Cherry Grove Beach — The public beach is a welcoming, mixed space
Women-Only Accommodation
- Wisteria — A women-only guest house in Cherry Grove with modern rooms and a relaxing atmosphere, specifically designed as a retreat for queer women
Community & History
The 2013 addition of the Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre to the National Register of Historic Places recognized the contributions of both gay men and lesbians to the community. The Fire Island Artist Residency has also featured a Lesbian Narratives Project documenting queer women's stories on the island.
Browse all LGBTQ+ venues in Fire Island on Out x Out.
Explore Fire Island
Never miss a night out when traveling or at home
Free on iOS and Android
Events x City Guides Delivered Weekly
Catch your city's vibe or the global LGBTQ+ scene.
No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
From the Blog
View all →Cherry Grove, Fire Island: The Complete Gay Guide 2026
Cherry Grove is where gay America summered before there was a word for it. Here's the complete guide to Fire Island's original queer hamlet — its history, its drag-soaked nightlife, where to stay and eat, the beach, and how it differs from the Pines next door.
Robbie S.Fire Island Pines: The Complete Gay Guide 2026
The Fire Island Pines is the glamorous, modernist, party heart of gay Fire Island. Here's the complete guide — its architecture and history, the tea-dance nightlife, where to stay and eat, the beach, and the marquee events, plus how it differs from Cherry Grove.
Robbie S.Where to Eat on Fire Island 2026: The Cherry Grove & Pines Dining Guide
Dining on Fire Island is casual, harbor-side, and woven into the rhythm of the day. Here's where to eat across Cherry Grove and the Pines — the sit-down dinners, the coffee-and-provisions spots, the late-night slice, plus how to provision a share house.
Robbie S.