Are There Lesbian Bars and Safe Spaces in Fire Island?

Fire Island's Cherry Grove has deep roots as a lesbian community — queer women began summering there in the 1950s, and the community has been a safe haven ever since. The historian Esther Newton documented this history in her book Cherry Grove, Fire Island: Sixty Years in America's First Gay and Lesbian Town.

Cherry Grove — The Heart of Queer Women's Fire Island

While Fire Island doesn't have a dedicated lesbian bar, Cherry Grove is the more gender-diverse of the two gay communities, with a strong presence of queer women, non-binary people, and LGBTQ+ families. The entire village functions as a safe space.

• The Ice Palace — Hosts events and parties that draw a mixed, inclusive crowd including many queer women
• Cherry's On The Bay — The waterfront restaurant and bar is a popular gathering spot for all parts of the community
• Arts Project of Cherry Grove — The community theater regularly features queer women artists, playwrights, and performers in its summer season programming
• Cherry Grove Beach — The public beach is a welcoming, mixed space

Women-Only Accommodation

• Wisteria — A women-only guest house in Cherry Grove with modern rooms and a relaxing atmosphere, specifically designed as a retreat for queer women

Community & History

Cherry Grove's designation as a National Historic District in 2024 recognized the contributions of both gay men and lesbians to the community. The Fire Island Artist Residency has also featured a Lesbian Narratives Project documenting queer women's stories on the island.

Browse all LGBTQ+ venues in Fire Island on Out x Out.