Pines Pizza, Fire Island

About Pines Pizza

Pines Pizza is the casual pizza counter in the Fire Island Pines harbor district, the quick-bite spot between the beach, the pool, and the bars. It does slices and whole pies plus salads, grab-and-go meals, and all-day coffee, with a deck looking out over Fire Island Boulevard. In a tiny, ferry-only village with a short list of places to eat, it's the dependable daytime stop — fast, counter service, and exactly what a long beach day calls for. It runs seasonally, roughly from early spring into September alongside the rest of the Pines summer machine. Order at the counter, grab a harbor-side seat, and watch the ferry come in — straightforward food in a place where the scenery does the heavy lifting.